Over the past 18 months, I’ve watched the ground shift under support leaders. For many support leaders, the world before and after AI feels drastically different—and I feel it too.
Rewind to before Q1 of 2023, and while the details varied, the challenges support leaders faced were largely the same as they had been for decades. Before AI, support leaders were tasked with improving the customer experience with under-resourced teams; finding ways to improve the cost-to-revenue ratio; preventing team attrition (despite managing people with difficult jobs and low compensation); and representing customers’ needs to teams with competing priorities.
Support was expected to operate behind the scenes, often absorbing work from other departments. Despite being essential for customer retention, it was still viewed primarily as a cost center, and leaders rarely had strong executive advocacy. Those conditions sharpened valuable muscles—creativity, scrappiness, and people leadership—but they didn’t prepare most teams to operate in an AI-first world.
Now with AI, the mandate has expanded. The core responsibilities persist, but the “how” has changed. Leaders are suddenly expected to be AI experts, spearhead large AI implementation initiatives, and keep operations rock-solid while the plane is being rebuilt mid-flight.
They’re being asked to step out from behind the scenes to center stage and lead the company in its first large adoption of AI. They’re being asked to regularly communicate with executives who previously had little interest in their initiatives or ideas. They’re being asked to run high-lift, high-impact, cross-functional projects without the infrastructure in place to manage it. They’re also now expected to hit AI performance metrics that an executive heard somewhere were possible—targets that might be unrealistic for the actual use case.
Oh, and if they fail, they’ll likely lose their job. And if they succeed, they could cause job loss for their team members. I’ve felt that tension firsthand: accelerate AI to drive outcomes, while also protecting the humans who make your customer experience exceptional.
It’s tempting to wait for the storm to pass—to delay AI change until someone else takes it over and hope they don’t undo what you’ve built. I’ve seen that playbook, and it rarely ends well.
There’s a better approach: harness the storm’s energy to elevate your customer experience, your team, and your own influence.
Harnessing AI’s momentum
This new era can reduce your support operation to a transactional, robotic experience—or transform it into what you’ve always envisioned. The outcome depends on how you respond to the demand to implement AI. This is one of the most unique opportunities of your career: you will have your executives’ attention, unprecedented access to product and engineering resources, and far less friction persuading stakeholders that change is essential for customers and the business.
With the right plan, you can reframe your team from cost center to value driver, expand services instead of sweating basic metrics, and move from surviving to thriving.
Here are the three areas I encourage every support leader to master.
Become the AI subject matter expert
Start by learning. Understand what is actually possible with AI now, and what may be possible in the near future. Go at least a layer or two deeper than the average person using ChatGPT. Know what it takes to implement more than a glorified answer bot—especially if your goal is end-to-end resolution, not just deflection.
Then anticipate the pitfalls I see most often in AI adoption.
Not digging deep enough with vendors. Demos often look similar and impressive with minimal lift. The truth emerges in a proof of concept. Run multiple trials with different vendors to uncover real capabilities and limitations—and to calibrate what “good” looks like for your environment.
Only finding a technology solution, not a partnership. Many tools can deliver similar outcomes; partners are not interchangeable. Choose a vendor whose values align with yours, who will support your use cases post-sale, who moves at a pace you can absorb, and who is committed for the long haul (not merely positioning for acquisition in a year or two).
Not knowing what good actually looks like. Ask each vendor about AI involvement rate and AI resolution rate. Ask what AI CSAT typically looks like in your industry. Document these answers to build benchmarks and set realistic expectations with executives.
Not learning from others’ mistakes. Many teams have overestimated AI’s impact and underestimated the human resources still required. Some laid off hundreds of support team members—only to rehire later—damaging their brand and wasting resources. Move with purpose and pace, but not so fast that you repeat these mistakes.
Not communicating your plan effectively. Be able to articulate why deflecting 50% of inquiry volume does not equal a 50% headcount reduction. Cite logistics like coverage windows and redundancy for SLAs, growth needs, natural attrition, and all the non-inquiry work your team handles. Practice a concise, compelling rationale for executives.
Create a clear AI plan
Your company is in uncharted territory. Unless you’ve hired a specialist recently, none of your executives have deployed AI in support. That makes you the most qualified person to draw the map and lead the way. Here’s what your plan should include.
1) A vendor evaluation plan. Define how you’ll research providers, who advances from demo to trial, how many you’ll test, and in what timeframe. Establish criteria for what AI must accomplish and the effectiveness and quality metrics you’ll use to evaluate it.
2) Implementation phases. AI is not a “set it and forget it” tool. Because AI touches customers so quickly, mitigate risk with phased rollouts. Phases don’t have to be slow—just deliberate. Sequence by audience, use case, and channel, and publish a clear timeline so cross-functional partners can plan resources.
3) How you’ll measure success. Reuse your evaluation metrics and go deeper. Track AI involvement rate and AI resolution rate (together, your deflection rate). Measure quality through CSAT and CX Scores, and run regular QA. Quantify impact on your support cost-to-revenue ratio—your CFO cares deeply about this.
4) How your team will use reclaimed time. If your AI program frees 20% of capacity, what value will you create? How will you improve the customer experience, drive revenue or retention, and upskill your team? Quantify the upside and set milestones for capability-building and value-added work. If you fail to plan this, you will be pushed to let too many people go.
5) How you’ll report on progress. Communication failures sink AI programs. Align with your executive sponsor on format and cadence, then over-communicate—regularly, clearly, concisely. You can’t afford to under-communicate.
Own the initiative at a higher level
Support leaders are great at taking ownership, often absorbing projects other teams drop. This initiative is different: it’s highly visible and enterprise-critical. Treat it like a flagship product rollout.
Project management. Use a tool your team can execute in and that lets you summarize progress succinctly for executives. Borrow best practices from your product managers and signal early that you’ll be partnering with them. Learn your sponsor’s preferred update style and tailor to it.
Communication. Overcommunicate—with brevity and rhythm. Don’t let a week pass without your sponsor knowing status. For executives, I recommend weekly or bi-weekly updates with a one-line summary, three impact statements, and a link to the plan. For example: “Saved customers 30K waiting hours M/M,” “Improved full resolution time by 30% M/M,” “Next initiative will improve X metric by Y%.”
Showcase your thought leadership. Reference industry benchmarks proactively when you set goals, and reactively when questions arise. Having succinct, data-backed answers that tie to benchmarks signals expertise and builds trust.
The storm is here—what will you do?
The pressure around AI is intensifying and isn’t fading anytime soon. This storm can crush your team as you know it—or become the wind under your wings that elevates your support operation to its maximum potential. The choice is yours: wait and risk cuts, or step up as the support AI expert, form a plan, and transform your team into a value engine. I’ve chosen the latter—and I invite you to do the same.
Inspired by this post on The Intercom Blog.
Leave a Reply